COMMENTS:
 

Carole Kropscot	The original is unique-looking in its shapes and coloring. Then adding an edited version on either side has created even more special interest. I have seen this multiple image presentation before, but done with different colors instead of effects. I like your choices.
Jenny Gu	Good title of "Pine Tree Trio" and very nice techniques.  It opens my view on using Photoshop.  So many artistic effect could be created using Photoshop.  The color gives me the feeling of very quiet full moon night.  I love these photos.
David Price	Nice triptych. The original is perfectly exposed, and the treatments either side combine to make an interesting result. Maybe you could have cloned out the bright star bottom right in all three images as it draws the eye and is distracting from the overall display.
Ruth Rittichier	I love your original just as it is. Wouldn't change a thing. There's the smoothness of the moon, juxtaposed against the jagged branches, plus the simplicity but hidden complexity of the whole thing. Sometimes less is more.
Walter Ross	This is a super mural depicting night.  I like the way you added the straight image in the middle. The white border really adds to the impact of the total image.
Joann Greene	I love how you took this differently then we all did and made it into a collage. The stars in this picture add to it, and I am glad that you were able to get them in the background.